Pages

Friday, December 20, 2013

Closed FXI Naked Put on Expiration Date


I finally closed the short Dec$37.50 puts on FXI today by buying them back at a cost of $0.13. I decided to take a good amount of profit on the expiration date, rather than getting assigned to FXI as the stock price was a few cents below strike.The intention is to sell another put when FXI rebounds.

As a winner management strategy, I could have set an good till cancel order to buy back the short put at a price of $0.10 to reduce risk of getting assigned when FXI fell. This option price was reached recently intraday, but not at the AM time period when I was trading.

I'll post the complete time decay chart of this option later with further analysis of the put selling strategy in the next few days.



Created with ProphetCharts®

Sunday, December 8, 2013

The time decay chart of a put option adjusted by Delta

Time decay is a fascinating part of option premium selling strategy. In my quest searching for suitable time decay, I'd like to get clear picture in areas such as what are good entry and exit points that capture rapid option time decay in a option's life span. I had posted a conceptual OTM option time decay chart  and an actual OTM time decay chart before. This time, I further studied the time decay of my naked FXI put option sold 3 weeks ago with the help of ThinkScript.

Since option price changes with underlying stock due to the impact of Delta, I decided to observe the option premium decay after taking out the Delta-induced option price changes. The option time value in my study was restricted to changes due to volatility (Vega) and Theta mainly in this way:
Option time value = extrinsic value  =
previous price + Delta-induced change + sum of Vega and Theta induced changes.

Using a simple approximation of Delta-induced option price changes, I was able to chart the Delta-adjusted time decay curve of the naked put which took out the Delta-induced change in the above equation. The directional price change from Delta is calculated as shown below using ThinkScript:
plot TmValExclDelta = extrVal - ((absValue(Delta()) + gamma() * opChange)/2) * (opChange);
The entire script is downloadable for anyone who is interested. It can be used as a base for other option premium analysis. The resulted chart is downloadable in a PDF file if anyone needs to see a clearer picture.
As shown in the above chart, I found a few key points below. I think a picture is worthless a thousand words. There are other points that can be observed from it as well. Note the left vertical axis is FXI ETF price and right vertical axis is FXI Dec$37.5 put option price.
  • The FXI option price was high while its time value was low as FXI dropped below the strike price.
  • The FXI option time decay acceleration started at about 2.5 months before expiration.
  • The naked put sold at Delta around 0.3 and its time decay stayed close to the bottom downtrending line as FXI price consolidated for 3 weeks.
One of the interesting point to me is that this option started rapid decay around 2.5 months. If one sells the option on 2.5 months before expiration and exit it at around 1 month before expiration, he would capture a good amount of premium values with relatively smooth time decay as well. 

Sunday, December 1, 2013

OTM Option Time Decay and its Exit Time

TastyTrade posted a video on Theta Based Exits for Sold Options on Youtube. It was quite educational. I’d like to share with everyone some of my review and thoughts on this topic.

On the time decay part, we sell options of delta of 0.30 to 0.35, which implies the ITM probability around 30% to 35% by expiration date. A credit is received after the option selling, which is similar to selling insurance premium. The OTM option time decay manner is somewhat different from that of ATM options which is show-cased in a lot of option text books. Based on the video introduction, the OTM option with Delta around 0.33 has a time decay chart as shown below. [Note I believe the hosts made a minor error in describing the units of the axes. The horizontal axis represent the passing time of the option in weeks (not days as they said) for an option that expires in 10 weeks. The vertical axis is the   option price x 100 in Dollars (not option price as they mentioned).]

For OTM options, the option’s price is the same as its extrinsic value. Time decay functions similar to insurance premium. This chart suggests OTM option (Delta = 0.33) price decay is relatively faster at around the first 7 weeks (49 days), which is the inflection point. After that, the time decay slows down as the price of the option has already dropped significantly and there is not much value left. The big assumption is that the OTM option stays OTM, although it was not elaborated how much price movement of the underlying could have to maintain such as time decay pattern. The discussion seemed to suggest that this 0.30 ~ 0.35 Delta OTM time decay chart is the merge of a 0.4 ~ 0.6 Delta ATM option at the 1st few weeks and a 0.1 ~ 0.2 Delta OTM option at the last few weeks.

In reality, it may be difficult to come up with the above curve for any specific options, as prices always fluctuate. Demonstrating the daily rate of return on capital (ROC) in a chart is also interesting and it can give very good clues on when to exit this type of trades. Thus, this is one area that I intend to investigate in the future with the help of ThinkScript.

On the management of winners using Theta decay for exits, I believe it’s a great rule and Tom has been telling many of his students for a long time. Once most of the premium is decayed through time, the remaining value is quite small and the rate of decay becomes very slow. From risk to reward perspective, it will not look good if we try to gain a small reward that remains in the last couple of weeks before expiration. Therefore, it makes sense to buy back the sold option in the last couple of weeks immediately after the inflection point, as the return of capital gets smaller.

TOS offers free trades for option buy-backs within a nickel. However, many options at the inflection points are likely to be worth above $0.05. Only very low priced options can meet the free commission trade criteria. It would be much helpful for retail traders if TOS could offer free buy back trades at the inflection points such as Delta <= 0.10 or price <=  $0.10 J

Where should be a good point of entry to sell the options? This is not discussed in this video. But from the chart, it appears to tell us that 8 to 7 weeks before expiration is a good entry point where the option starts to accelerate its time decay. This entry point coincides with the option selling days used by Supertrade Karen.

In summary, the video discussed option premium selling by exploring the relationship of statistical probability (success rate and occurrence rate), return on capital, and management of winners. It did not use the option Greeks that much. Even though Theta had been mentioned in the whole discussion, the value of Theta or the trend of Theta was not shown at all.

The so called “Theta based exit” should be more accurately named as “Time decay based exit” in my opinion as Theta is only one component of the time decay. The other components for time decay include implied volatility/Vega and Delta which also change with time. There is no guarantee that Theta provides the most time decay when compared to Vega and Delta.

Wednesday, November 20, 2013

Added more TBT call contracts


TBT retraced about 5 days after my recent purchase of its 2014 Jun$73 call, then it started to resume up trend from yesterday. I liked its orderly pullback and the current upward candle today. So I doubled my long contracts by adding June$74c on TBT at a mid price of $7.70.

I'm considering raising my stop loss point to somewhere below the upper line of the recent downtrending channel if case the trade works against me.

I also prefer to wait a couple of more weeks before I consider selling calls to convert this trade to diagonal spread, unless the price and volume action change significantly from current trend.


Created with ProphetCharts®

Saturday, November 16, 2013

Skeptical about super trader Karen's strategy and performance?

Since I posted about Super trader Karen's option selling strategy, I have received a couple of anonymous comments questioning about her strategy and trading performance. Other on-line trading forums have a lot more critics of the trading performance of Karen, the super trader. So I'd like to share my 2 cents as well. Please note I'm not affiliated with Tom or Karen. They don't know me at all, at this time of my writing.

I was educated by Investools (same stock/option education company that Karen attended) and by TOS (founded by Tom) in option trading. I happened to attend a few seminars presented by Tom, the interviewer of the Karen. Thus, I believe Tom is a successful and honest businessman. So it's hard for me to believe he would lie about his client (Karen) in TOS. In my humble opinion, there is no dispute among option traders that selling option premium is the most consistent way to profit on stock option trades. Karen's option selling strategy appears to be sound and logical for me. [Update: I'd like to stress that the system and the rules disclosed in the interviews should be far more important than the phenomenal profits for traders who are process-focused.]

A lot of people know solid option trading strategies as they are taught by many education experts but only very few limited numbers of them actually make money for living using these strategies. I think Karen is one of the successful option traders who made millions of dollars. Her trading performance in the time frame discussed in the interview video was exceptional, as Tom stated in the interview repeatedly. It's so exceptional that Tom and other option education experts could not achieve. It also means all other traders are not likely to achieve unless they become really exceptional too. Exceptional also suggests the excellent performance may not last forever. Since Karen's strategy involves probability, I believe it's possible to calculate the expected rate of return in estimation. Anyone who can keep the rate of return should be considered as a successful trader of this strategy. This should be the target many of us trying to reach.

To make a good judgement about this option strategy and its potential performance, traders must understand its principles first. Many of the critics online do not provide enough substances in their comments. But I still like any critics about the strategy itself and its published rules. Otherwise, I suggest to put accusations in other on-line forums.

Friday, November 15, 2013

Sold Dec$37.5p on FXI


FXI gapped up and broke up the 2 month down trending channel today with high volume. Since I'm bullish on China over long term, I looked for a way to play this ETF. My rules require me to see a 6 week retrace from overbought zone for the MS line in order to enter an uptrend trade. But FXI MS is dropping for about 4 weeks only. Thus I used the naked put strategy as it requires FXI to move sideways or up. FXI also has a high cor-relationship with SPX. So I felt it's saver with the naked put as US market has been running up without a rest for quite some time. I plan to keep FXI if the put has to be exercised later. My cost will be 37.5-0.68 = $36.82. TOS indicated a 18% annual return rate.


Created with ProphetCharts®

Friday, November 8, 2013

TBT: Profit from higher interest rates


Interest rate sensitive ETF's reacted on Government job numbers strongly today. TBT jumped above the recent 2 month long down trending channel with strong volume. My naked put Dec$70p sold about 10 days ago reached most of its profit with current Delta 0.09 in a surprising period of short time. So I bought them back for $0.25 each to nail down the profits and initiated some June$73c contracts for a longer term trade at the cost of $8.5 each. My stop loss will be around the recent low of $71. If TBT pulls back without heavy volume, I'll look for an opportunity to double my contracts. I'm impressed by the large pullback yesterday and the huge breakout today. The trade is consistent with my long term view of the interest rate rise. I'll change it to diagonal call spread later when I see TBT become far extended in price.

Another major beneficiary of the rising interest rate is the regional banks ETF KRE which also made an impressive breakout with huge volume today. I'll continue to investigate the possibility of playing with this ETF in the future. The real estate ETF's IYR got hammered again as a result.


Created with ProphetCharts®

Tuesday, October 29, 2013

Sold TBT Dec$70p after its pullback for 2 months


TBT had risen for 4 months then started falling. Its price is around the support of an uptrending 200 DMA at $70. Since I expect an rising interest rate environment over the longer term, I sold Dec$70 put for $1.23 to get a cost of $68.77 in case I get assigned.

The average implied volatility shown in the chart appears to follow the price performance of TBT, due to its inverse relationship with market. This is different from other regular stocks. TOS option chain window indicated the covered return rate of 11.5% for this trade.

Similar to USO, TBT has a relative loose correlation with stock market. This gives me an opportunity to play the overheated market in the short team.


Created with ProphetCharts®

Saturday, October 19, 2013

Are there any ETF's remaining to be heated as SPY breaking into new highs

With the red hot market today, are there anything left with good potential for long term investment but not too overbought? I found two ETF's that looked interesting: USO (Crude oil) & DXJ (Japanese stock market). Both of them have smaller correlations with the US stock market performance.

With energy stocks performing well and US dollar falling, I don't think USO will keep dropping, particularly if Chinese economy remains healthy. My guess of the weak USO is due to the improved prospects of peace in middle east (Iran). I read one article stating oil price could drop 20% or more if Iran's oil is available. That may lead USO to $29 level from current $36.45, a $7.00 drop. At current option price, it will take about 1 year of selling call options for around $0.40 premiums to break-even, if one enters USO from selling puts with a break-even price of around $35.00. With the outline shown in the study, it's probably worth try to sell some puts on USO soon if USO price rises next day.

DXJ chart looks similar to that of EWJ which follows the Japanese stock market index I believe. I choose DXJ because it's of higher price with more option strikes. My understanding is that they have an export driven economy which benefit from falling yen FXY: It's beneficial for the Japanese market if US dollar UUP behaves stronger than FXY. The low interest rate environment in Japan should be reflected in the rising of Japanese bond GJBL. As shown in the 2nd page of the study, Japanese bound ETF JGBL is currently outperforming US Bond. So it looks to me that Japanese market may continue to perform well since it shot up about one year ago when the current Japanese prime minister adopted a new economic policy to pump even more money into its already heavy debt economy.

Saturday, October 12, 2013

A study on Chinese ETF's

Since I bought HAO about 4 weeks ago, it was doing well as US market had some turbulence because American politicians played their threatening games for government closure and national debt ceiling. But I need to clarify my long term exit criteria for HAO. As part of my study for Chinese stock market conditions, I found the following interesting ETF's that are helpful to determine the health of China's economic status as reflected by Wall street.

Besides the Chinese big caps in FXI, we have the small cap HAO and Chinese technology CQQQ representing broad Chinese market. The Chinese bull market is led by the technology ETF CQQQ as it has rose over 50% year today. The Chinese real estate ETF TAO is lagging SPX but outperformed US real estate IYR (TAO provides no dividend) at this time. The thinly-traded China Energy ETF CHIE also showed an uptrend in the last 3 month.

The Chinese bond ETF DSUM has outperformed US bond ETF BOND manged by the bond king Bill Gross in the last 6 month. The Chinese Yuan ETF CYB outperform US dollar UUP and bond BOND in the same period. I think the Yuan price indicates longer term economic trends in China than the stock market prices.

If the Chinese economy is to collapse, I would expect the Chinese stock market ETF FXI, and bond market DSUM and the Yuan CYB to fall at the same time. If they don't drop at the same time, it's telling me that the Chinese economic may be healthy overall in the long run.

Additionally, Chinese economy has strong impact on commodities DBC and their producing countries like Australia EWA and its currency FXA. These ETF's are likely to lag the Chinese counterparts in time and to perform well later if Chinese ETF's gets real hot.